37 Puzzle games like That's Not My Neighbor that you should try

Games like That's Not My Neighbor · Find similar →

Ranking compiled by Lluis Enric Mayans, Founder & Head of ContentUpdated May 19, 2026How this is calculatedOrdered by an attribute-similarity model, not editorial opinion.

Filter by:Puzzle×← Back to home

We filtered the 48 games similar to That's Not My Neighbor down to the 37 that fit the “Puzzle” category. MiSide, Pony Island and Five Nights at Freddy's 3 top the list, ranked by affinity and similarity score to That's Not My Neighbor.

iRank85/ 100

Did you find what you were looking for?

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

The best puzzle games like That's Not My Neighbor

37 similar games foundUpdated May 2026

Handpicked by our similarity algorithm, these are the titles with the highest gameplay match to That's Not My Neighbor. Each one has been evaluated across 12 real attributes — from combat style and progression mechanics to world structure and visual perspective — so every recommendation is based on how the game actually plays, not just its genre label.

#1MiSideClosest overall match

iRank92

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorFirst Person2D

Steam👍 98%· 138KRAWG👍 84%· 137

Year 2024Dev AIHASTO · IndieArkPlaytime ~5hOn PC

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, adventure storytelling and deep simulation

≠ Where it differs: brings deep RPG systems, cozy, relaxing feel and setting anime, while skipping vibe casual

Tips※This game contains intense scenes. It is not recommended for those with weak hearts. About the Game Every day, you will come to see me, help me with chores, cook for me, and buy me gifts.You are so nice! I love you!

Genre100Game mode100Setting77Visuals61Tone54

Details →

Steam itch.io

#2Pony IslandClosest on setting

iRank92

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 95%· 18KIGDB92· 3OC85· 17

Year 2016Dev Daniel Mullins GamesOn Linux · PC · Mac

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, puzzle design and deep simulation

≠ Its own twist: cozy, relaxing feel and visual pixel, while skipping vibe casual

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: visuals.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 8 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Tone66Visuals42

Details →

Steam

#3Five Nights at Freddy's 3

iRank85

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 90%· 11KIGDB75· 1

Year 2015Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, deep simulation and adventure storytelling

≠ Where it differs: brings survival mechanics, punishing difficulty and melee combat, while skipping vibe casual

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 9 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Visuals73Tone57

Details →

Steam

#4Five Nights at Freddy's 2

iRank86

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 94%· 26KIGDB70· 1

Year 2014Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Both are psychological horror — sharing horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Stands apart with survival mechanics and punishing difficulty, while skipping vibe casual

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 10 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Visuals73Tone56

Details →

Steam

#5Five Nights at Freddy's

iRank87

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 94%· 58KIGDB72· 3

Year 2014Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, deep simulation and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: survival mechanics, punishing difficulty and resource management, while skipping vibe casual

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: progression.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 10 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Visuals73Tone57Progression0

Details →

Steam

#6Rusty Lake HotelClosest on tone

iRank96

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkCasualHorrorFirst Person2D

Steam👍 96%· 10K

Year 2015Dev Rusty LakeOn Android · PC · iOS

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 9 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals100

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeCasualDarkHorrorFirst Person2D

Steam👍 96%· 3.0KRAWG👍 80%· 25IGDB80· 1OC73· 8

Year 2019Dev Gabe Lane · LimboLanePlaytime ~4hOn PC · Apple Macintosh

✓ Both are psychological horror — sharing horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Its own twist: deep RPG systems, cozy, relaxing feel and linear, story-driven structure, while skipping deep simulation

Smile For Me is an unconventional Point-and-Click Adventure Game that puts you at the center of an abstract world! Nod and shake your head to chat with new friends, and solve their mysteries to cheer them up. The People are bizarre, the Puzzles are Wack, and the World hides a sinister secret...

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Tone79Visuals73

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkCasualHorror2D

Steam👍 97%· 27K

Year 2016Dev Portable MooseOn Xbox · PS4 · Linux

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 8 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals62

Details →

Steam GOG Xbox

#9The Witch's House MV

iRank90

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloCasualDarkNarrativeHorror2D

Steam👍 95%· 3.9KRAWG👍 91%· 45OC80· 5

Year 2018Dev Fummy · DANGEN EntertainmentPlaytime ~3hOn PC · Apple Macintosh · Nintendo

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Where it differs: brings deep RPG systems, survival mechanics and setting anime, while skipping deep simulation

The Witch’s House, originally released in 2012, falls within the tradition of Japanese horror RPGs with heavy emphasis on puzzle-solving and jump scares. Among other entries in the genre such as Ib and Ao Oni, The Witch’s House surprised fans with pixel-art that conceals truly frightening horror.

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: visuals.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting84Visuals46

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeCasualDarkHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 72%· 2.4KIGDB64· 11OC70· 101

Year 2019Dev Bloober Team · Gun InteractiveOn PS4 · PC · Xbox

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: exploration and discovery, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: progression.

On reception: its Steam reviews are mostly positive, against very positive for That's Not My Neighbor.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals73Progression0

Details →

Steam GOG Epic

#11Daylight

iRank44

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloCasualNarrativeDarkHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 50%· 1.6KRAWG👍 22%· 45MC51IGDB50· 10OC50· 57

Year 2014Dev Atlus U.S.A · Zombie StudiosPlaytime ~2hOn PC · PS

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with survival mechanics, procedural generation and melee combat, while skipping deep simulation

You awake, trapped in an abandoned hospital. Your only source of light is your phone. You hit a dead-end and must turn around, but behind you lurks an eerie presence and strange noises... Experience Daylight, a procedurally generated psychological thriller for your PC.

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: progression.

On reception: its Steam reviews are mixed, against very positive for That's Not My Neighbor.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 10 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals73Progression0

Details →

Steam PS

#12Mad Father

iRank97

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkCasualHorror2D

Steam👍 97%· 6.5K

Year 2012Dev Sen · PLAYISMOn PC · Mac · Switch

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: survival mechanics, setting anime and exploration and discovery, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: progression and visuals.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 12 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting61Visuals32Progression0

Details →

Steam Nintendo

#13The Supper

iRank99

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeCasualDarkHorror

Steam👍 99%· 4.4K

Year 2020Dev Octavi NavarroOn PC

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: visual pixel and free to play, while skipping deep simulation

The Supper is a short adventure game about the darkest side of the human soul. Ms. Appleton was always a wellspring of kindness, until The Voice started talking to her. It won't leave her alone. It commands her to serve a very special meal to some distinguished customers.

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: visuals.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals0

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeCasualDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 93%· 7.2KIGDB70· 1

Year 2013Dev House on FireOn Android · PC · iOS

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Where it differs: brings deep RPG systems, linear, story-driven structure and setting scifi, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from That's Not My Neighbor: progression and setting.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 11 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Tone100Visuals63Setting33Progression0

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 97%· 8.7K

Year 2016Dev Rusty LakeOn Android · PC · iOS

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

It predates That's Not My Neighbor by 8 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Tone69Visuals62

Details →

Steam GOG itch.io

Complete list of puzzle games like That's Not My Neighbor

The full catalog of games sharing gameplay DNA with That's Not My Neighbor, ordered from highest to lowest similarity score. Use the filters above to narrow down by genre, setting or game mode and find the alternative that best fits your playstyle.