Ultimate Custom Night

24 Puzzle games like Ultimate Custom Night that you should try

Games like Ultimate Custom Night · Find similar →

More about this game →

Ranking compiled by Lluis Enric Mayans, Founder & Head of ContentUpdated May 19, 2026How this is calculatedOrdered by an attribute-similarity model, not editorial opinion.

Filter by:Puzzle×← Back to home

We filtered the 48 games similar to Ultimate Custom Night down to the 24 that fit the “Puzzle” category. Tea Party Simulator 2015, Shoppy Mart: Steam Edition and Five Nights at Freddy's 3 top the list, ranked by affinity and similarity score to Ultimate Custom Night.

iRank87/ 100

Did you find what you were looking for?

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

Tags

HardcoreDarkSolo

Year 2018Dev Scottgames

Stores

Quick answer

Within the “Puzzle” category, the closest game to Ultimate Custom Night is Tea Party Simulator 2015 — scoring 79/100 on our similarity scale. Shoppy Mart: Steam Edition and Five Nights at Freddy's 3 follow close behind.

#1Tea Party Simulator 201579 #2Shoppy Mart: Steam Edition78 #3Five Nights at Freddy's 355 #4Five Nights at Freddy's 250 #5Five Nights at Freddy's49

🗳️

Help us build the best rankings

Community powered

Vote on each result below — good match or not. Every vote directly shapes how we rank similar games for everyone.

The best puzzle games like Ultimate Custom Night

24 similar games foundUpdated May 2026

Handpicked by our similarity algorithm, these are the titles with the highest gameplay match to Ultimate Custom Night. Each one has been evaluated across 14 real attributes — from combat style and progression mechanics to world structure and visual perspective — so every recommendation is based on how the game actually plays, not just its genre label.

#1Tea Party Simulator 2015Closest overall match

79

Tea Party Simulator 2015

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeHorrorCasual

Steam👍 69%· 669RAWG👍 4%· 25

Year 2015Dev Power Up to MaximumPlaytime ~5hOn PC · Apple Macintosh · Linux

✓ Fits the action horror games cluster, with horror tension, deep simulation and survival mechanics

≠ Its own twist: vibe casual, cozy, relaxing feel and post-apocalyptic world, while skipping punishing difficulty

Ever wanted to be a tea party extraordinaire? Well now you can. Brew the tea, pour the tea, serve the tea. Serve biscuits and cake. Try not to mess it up too bad, or your guest will get angry Find the hidden easter eggs You know...

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: tone.

On reception: its Steam reviews are mixed, against very positive for Ultimate Custom Night.

Genre100Combat100Game mode100Setting63Tone23

#2Shoppy Mart: Steam EditionClosest on setting

78

Shoppy Mart: Steam Edition

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloNarrativeHorrorFree to PlayCasual

Steam👍 70%· 92

Year 2015Dev PezomiPlaytime ~4hOn PC

✓ Same family of action horror games: horror tension, deep simulation and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: vibe casual, cozy, relaxing feel and linear, story-driven structure, while skipping punishing difficulty

Shoppy Mart: Steam Edition is the answer to the full grocery store cashier experience that many have dreamed about, and dozens asked for. Shoppy Mart puts you in the shoes of a grocery store cashier, where it is your job to scan items and stuff them into bags.

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: visuals and tone.

On reception: its Steam reviews are mixed, against very positive for Ultimate Custom Night.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Tone20Visuals0

#3Five Nights at Freddy's 3Closest on tone

55

Five Nights at Freddy's 3

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloMeleeDarkNarrativeHardcoreHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 90%· 11KIGDB75· 1

Year 2015Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, deep simulation and adventure storytelling.

≠ Missing: skill tree progression.

Same studio: Scottgames.

Combat100Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals100Genre50

#4Five Nights at Freddy's 2

50

Five Nights at Freddy's 2

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkHardcoreNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 94%· 26KIGDB70· 1

Year 2014Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling.

≠ Missing: melee combat.

Same studio: Scottgames.

Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals100Genre50

#5Five Nights at Freddy's

49

Five Nights at Freddy's

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHardcoreHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 94%· 58KIGDB72· 3

Year 2014Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Like Ultimate Custom Night, it's known for horror tension, deep simulation and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: resource management, while skipping melee combat

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: progression.

Same studio: Scottgames.

Game mode100Tone100Setting100Visuals100Genre50Progression0

#6Bendy and the Ink Machine

78

Bendy and the Ink Machine

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeDarkNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 89%· 35KIGDB87· 2OC69· 25

Year 2017Dev TheMeatly Games, Ltd. · Rooster Teeth GamesOn Xbox · PS4 · Linux

✓ Same family of action horror games: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with cozy, relaxing feel, fantasy world and setting cartoon, while skipping deep simulation

Genre100Combat100Game mode100Visuals100Tone58Setting58

#7Alone in the Dark

77

Alone in the Dark

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeDarkHorror

Steam👍 79%· 4.6KIGDB75· 4

Year 2024Dev Pieces Interactive · THQ NordicOn Xbox · PC · PS5

✓ Fits the action horror games cluster, with horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with visual third person, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: visuals.

On reception: its Steam reviews are mostly positive, against very positive for Ultimate Custom Night.

Released 6 years after Ultimate Custom Night.

Genre100Combat100Game mode100Setting100Tone70Visuals0

#8The Walking Dead: Michonne

76

The Walking Dead: Michonne

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeDarkNarrativeHorror

Steam👍 81%· 8.1KIGDB68· 4

Year 2016Dev Telltale GamesOn PlayStation 3 · PS4 · Android

✓ Both are action horror games — sharing horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with post-apocalyptic world and visual third person, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: visuals.

Genre100Combat100Game mode100Setting72Tone70Visuals0

#9The Walking Dead: The Final Season

76

The Walking Dead: The Final Season

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeDarkHorror

Steam👍 95%· 21KIGDB71· 5OC78· 30

Year 2018Dev Telltale GamesOn PS4 · PC · Xbox

✓ Fits the action horror games cluster, with horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Where it differs: brings post-apocalyptic world and visual third person, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: visuals.

Genre100Combat100Game mode100Tone70Setting69Visuals0

#10The Walking Dead: A New Frontier

76

The Walking Dead: A New Frontier

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeDarkHorror

Steam👍 83%· 18KIGDB75· 13

Year 2016Dev Telltale Games · Skybound GamesOn PS4 · Android · PC

✓ Same family of action horror games: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with post-apocalyptic world and visual third person, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: visuals.

Genre100Combat100Game mode100Tone71Setting64Visuals0

#11Penumbra Overture

75

Penumbra Overture

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeDarkNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 91%· 4.1KRAWG👍 74%· 237MC73IGDB74· 4

Year 2007Dev Frictional GamesPlaytime ~1hOn PC · Apple Macintosh · Linux

✓ Same family of action horror games: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Where it differs: brings stealth mechanics, while skipping deep simulation

Penumbra Overture is a survival horror game developed by Frictional Games. In the year 2001, after his mother's death, Phillip receives a message from his father who left the family and was supposedly dead. The letter leads Phillip to Greenland where he finds a mine his father wrote about.

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: combat.

It predates Ultimate Custom Night by 11 years, with what that implies technically.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Visuals100Tone63Combat37

#12Amnesia: Rebirth

73

Amnesia: Rebirth

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeDarkHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 77%· 9.2KIGDB82· 9OC78· 92

Year 2020Dev Frictional GamesOn Xbox · PS4 · Linux

✓ Both are action horror games — sharing horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Where it differs: brings stealth mechanics, fantasy world and exploration and discovery, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: progression and combat.

On reception: its Steam reviews are mostly positive, against very positive for Ultimate Custom Night.

Genre100Game mode100Visuals100Setting80Tone68Combat41

73

Soma

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeDarkHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 96%· 51KIGDB81· 15OC83· 94

Year 2015Dev Frictional GamesOn PS4 · Linux · PC

✓ Both are action horror games — sharing horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Where it differs: brings stealth mechanics, setting scifi and post-apocalyptic world, while skipping deep simulation

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: progression and combat.

Genre100Game mode100Visuals100Tone69Setting60Combat46

#14Killer Frequency

70

Killer Frequency

GenreHorrorSubgenreAction Horror

SoloNarrativeHorrorFirst PersonExploration

Steam👍 93%· 5.9KRAWG👍 92%· 22OC79· 29

Year 2023Dev Team17 DigitalPlaytime ~3hOn PC · PS

✓ Both are action horror games — sharing horror tension, deep simulation and adventure storytelling

≠ Its own twist: exploration and discovery, while skipping survival mechanics

The year is 1987, and as the clock strikes midnight in small-town Gallows Creek, USA, former big city radio DJ Forrest Nash is live on air in what will turn out to be the graveyard shift of a lifetime...

Where it drifts furthest from Ultimate Custom Night: progression and tone.

Released 5 years after Ultimate Custom Night.

Genre100Game mode100Setting100Visuals100Tone41Progression0

#15Poppy Playtime

47

Poppy Playtime

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloMeleeNarrativeDarkHorrorFirst PersonFree to Play

Steam👍 88%· 138K

Year 2021Dev Mob EntertainmentOn Xbox · PS4 · Android

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

Released 3 years after Ultimate Custom Night.

Combat100Game mode100Setting100Visuals100Tone65Genre50

Steam Epic Xbox

Complete list of puzzle games like Ultimate Custom Night

The full catalog of games sharing gameplay DNA with Ultimate Custom Night, ordered from highest to lowest similarity score. Use the filters above to narrow down by genre, setting or game mode and find the alternative that best fits your playstyle.

Daylight

Daylight

Horror · Adventure

Silent Hill Homecoming

Silent Hill Homecoming

Horror · Adventure

Erica

Erica

Horror · Puzzle

Lucius

Lucius

Horror · Adventure

Buckshot Roulette

Buckshot Roulette

Horror · Simulation

We Were Here Too

We Were Here Too

Horror · Puzzle

We Were Here Together

We Were Here Together

Horror · Puzzle

Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People: Season 1

Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People: Season 1

Horror · Puzzle

The Medium

The Medium

Horror · Adventure

Explore games similar to Ultimate Custom Night by category

Rankings in the same genre

Best Action Horror Games Best Horror Games