Games like Supernatural · Find similar →
More about this game →We filtered the 41 games similar to Supernatural down to the 12 that fit the “Puzzle” category. Prey, Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth and Scorn top the list, ranked by affinity and similarity score to Supernatural.
Did you find what you were looking for?
Quick answer
Within the “Puzzle” category, the closest game to Supernatural is Prey — scoring 94/100 on our similarity scale. Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth and Scorn follow close behind.
Help us build the best rankings
Community poweredVote on each result below — good match or not. Every vote directly shapes how we rank similar games for everyone.
Handpicked by our similarity algorithm, these are the titles with the highest gameplay match to Supernatural. Each one has been evaluated across 13 real attributes — from combat style and progression mechanics to world structure and visual perspective — so every recommendation is based on how the game actually plays, not just its genre label.
✓ Fits the first-person shooters cluster, with shooter, first-person shooting and adventure storytelling
≠ Its own twist: deep RPG systems, open world exploration and setting scifi
Where it drifts furthest from Supernatural: setting.
✓ Both are first-person shooters — sharing shooter, first-person shooting and horror tension
≠ Where it differs: brings combat magic, ranged combat and setting scifi
Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth is a first-person horror game that combines intense action and adventure elements. You will draw upon your skills in exploration, investigation, and combat while faced with the seemingly impossible task of battling evil incarnate.
It predates Supernatural by 19 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Fits the first-person shooters cluster, with shooter, first-person shooting and adventure storytelling
≠ Its own twist: deep RPG systems, open world exploration and ranged combat, while skipping survival mechanics
FPS with RPG elements, Bioshock invites players to experience horrors of underwater isolation in the city of Rapture, the failed project of the better future. After surviving the plane crash, the protagonist has only one way to go – to the giant lighthouse that opens a way to the underwater utopia.
It predates Supernatural by 17 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Both are first-person shooters — sharing shooter, first-person shooting and adventure storytelling
≠ Its own twist: setting anime, while skipping survival mechanics
It predates Supernatural by 19 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Same family of first-person shooters: shooter, first-person shooting and adventure storytelling
≠ Where it differs: brings ranged combat and setting scifi, while skipping horror tension
A short follow-up focused almost entirely on Alyx as a companion — the AI and dialogue work is what it was really testing, and it holds up. Roughly four hours. It is the slightest of the three: much of it is dark corridors and elevator sequences, and it functions more as a bridge than as a game in its own right.
Where it drifts furthest from Supernatural: combat.
It predates Supernatural by 18 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Same family of first-person shooters: shooter, first-person shooting and puzzle design
≠ Its own twist: deep RPG systems, open world exploration and setting cyberpunk, while skipping horror tension
Where it drifts furthest from Supernatural: setting.
It predates Supernatural by 13 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Nearly identical: shooter, first-person shooting and puzzle design.
≠ Missing: horror tension.
It predates Supernatural by 24 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Both are first-person shooters — sharing shooter, first-person shooting and puzzle design
≠ Where it differs: brings setting scifi and visual third person, while skipping horror tension
Where it drifts furthest from Supernatural: setting.
It predates Supernatural by 20 years, with what that implies technically.
✓ Same family of first-person shooters: shooter, first-person shooting and puzzle design
≠ Its own twist: precision platforming, Metroidvania exploration and open world exploration, while skipping horror tension
A first-person puzzle game structured like a metroidvania: a small sandbox where new tools retroactively open earlier areas, and almost every corner hides something. Puzzle design is genuinely clever. Combat is the weak part — enemies are simple damage sponges that interrupt the puzzling — and the art style is plain enough to look cheap.
Where it drifts furthest from Supernatural: combat.
✓ Both are first-person shooters — sharing shooter, first-person shooting and puzzle design
≠ Where it differs: brings multiplayer gameplay, while skipping horror tension
It predates Supernatural by 21 years, with what that implies technically.