14 Games with a horror setting like Rusty Lake Paradise that you should try

Games like Rusty Lake Paradise · Find similar →

We filtered the 46 games similar to Rusty Lake Paradise down to the 14 that fit the “Horror” category. Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes, Kindergarten 2 and The Beast Within: A Gabriel Knight Mystery top the list, ranked by affinity and similarity score to Rusty Lake Paradise.

iRank87/ 100

Did you find what you were looking for?

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

The best games with a horror setting like Rusty Lake Paradise

14 similar games foundUpdated July 2026

Handpicked by our similarity algorithm, these are the titles with the highest gameplay match to Rusty Lake Paradise. Each one has been evaluated across 8 real attributes — from combat style and progression mechanics to world structure and visual perspective — so every recommendation is based on how the game actually plays, not just its genre label.

#1Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes

iRank80

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 89%· 3.4KIGDB63· 3

Year 2012Dev rondomedia Marketing & Vertriebs GmbHOn PS4 · Linux · PC

✓ Shared with Rusty Lake Paradise: puzzle design, adventure storytelling and strong narrative focus

≠ Stands apart with turn-based strategy and ranged combat, while skipping horror tension

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkNarrativeHorror2D

Steam👍 98%· 5.6K

Dev SmashGamesPlaytime ~7hOn PC · PS · Apple Macintosh

✓ If you enjoyed Rusty Lake Paradise, expect puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Where it differs: brings deep RPG systems, melee combat and visual pixel

Details →

Steam

#3The Beast Within: A Gabriel Knight Mystery

iRank89

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorThird Person

Steam👍 92%· 302IGDB83· 1

Year 1995Dev Sierra On-LineOn PC · Mac

✓ Like Rusty Lake Paradise, it's known for puzzle design, adventure storytelling and dark, oppressive atmosphere

≠ Stands apart with visual third person, while skipping horror tension

Details →

Steam GOG

#4Kairo

iRank66

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorExploration

Steam👍 74%· 1.7KRAWG👍 35%· 48MC76IGDB80· 1

Year 2013Dev Locked Door Puzzle · Lupus StudiosPlaytime ~2hOn PC · Apple Macintosh · Linux

✓ Shared with Rusty Lake Paradise: puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Its own twist: exploration and discovery and visual first person, while skipping visual 2d

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkNarrativeHorror2D

Steam👍 97%· 10KRAWG👍 71%· 26

Year 2017Dev Sean Young · SmashGamesPlaytime ~3hOn PC · PS · Apple Macintosh

✓ If you enjoyed Rusty Lake Paradise, expect puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Stands apart with punishing difficulty, visual pixel and early access

Details →

Steam

#6Thumper

iRank88

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorMelee

Steam👍 92%· 4.4KIGDB84· 11OC84· 53

Year 2016Dev DroolOn PS4 · Android · PC

✓ If you enjoyed Rusty Lake Paradise, expect puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Stands apart with punishing difficulty, melee combat and visual third person, while skipping visual 2d

Details →

Steam PS Nintendo

#7Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon

iRank81

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkHorror2D

IGDB81· 12

Year 2013Dev Next Level Games · Nintendo

✓ Nearly identical: puzzle design, adventure storytelling and dark, oppressive atmosphere.

≠ Missing: horror tension.

Details →

Nintendo

#8The Room VR: A Dark Matter

iRank89

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeHorrorFirst Person

Steam👍 98%· 4.0KRAWG👍 86%· 28IGDB83· 3OC79· 13

Year 2020Dev Fireproof GamesPlaytime ~3hOn PC · PS

✓ Like Rusty Lake Paradise, it's known for puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Stands apart with visual first person, while skipping dark, oppressive atmosphere

Details →

Steam PS

#9The Room 4: Old Sins

iRank93

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeHorrorExplorationFirst Person

Steam👍 98%· 18KRAWG👍 92%· 97MC86

Year 2018Dev Fireproof GamesPlaytime ~5hOn PC · iOS · Android

✓ Like Rusty Lake Paradise, it's known for puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Its own twist: exploration and discovery, visual first person and visual 3d, while skipping dark, oppressive atmosphere

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorFantasy

Steam👍 95%· 13K

Year 2015Dev Fireproof GamesOn Android · PC · iOS

✓ Shared with Rusty Lake Paradise: puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Its own twist: fantasy world, setting scifi and visual first person, while skipping visual 2d

Details →

Steam

#11Paper Lily - Chapter 1

iRank99

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkHorrorIsometricPixel Art

Steam👍 99%· 8.3K

Year 2023Dev Leef 6010Playtime ~1hOn PC · Apple Macintosh · Linux

✓ Like Rusty Lake Paradise, it's known for puzzle design, adventure storytelling and dark, oppressive atmosphere

≠ Stands apart with deep RPG systems, visual isometric and visual pixel, while skipping horror tension

Details →

Steam itch.io

#12Ib

iRank85

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkHorrorIsometric

OC85· 11

Year 2012Dev kouriOn PC

✓ If you enjoyed Rusty Lake Paradise, expect puzzle design, adventure storytelling and dark, oppressive atmosphere

≠ Stands apart with visual isometric, while skipping horror tension

Details →

#13Distraint

iRank84

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloDarkHorror2DCasual

Steam👍 93%· 13KIGDB65· 2

Year 2015Dev Jesse MakkonenOn PC

✓ Like Rusty Lake Paradise, it's known for puzzle design, adventure storytelling and dark, oppressive atmosphere

≠ Stands apart with vibe casual, while skipping horror tension

GenrePuzzleSubgenreLogic Puzzle

SoloNarrativeHorrorFantasyFirst Person

Steam👍 98%· 21KRAWG👍 94%· 248MC88IGDB81· 4

Year 2013Dev Fireproof GamesPlaytime ~4hOn PC · iOS · Android

✓ If you enjoyed Rusty Lake Paradise, expect puzzle design, adventure storytelling and horror tension

≠ Its own twist: fantasy world and visual first person, while skipping dark, oppressive atmosphere

Details →

Steam

Explore games similar to Rusty Lake Paradise by category

Rankings in the same genre

Best Logic Puzzle Games Best Puzzle Games