Pony Island

35 Puzzle games like Pony Island that you should try

Games like Pony Island · Find similar →

More about this game →

Filter by:Puzzle×← Back to home

We filtered the 45 games similar to Pony Island down to the 35 that fit the “Puzzle” category. MiSide, Iron Lung and Five Nights at Freddy's top the list, ranked by affinity and similarity score to Pony Island.

iRank89/ 100

Did you find what you were looking for?

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

Tags

NarrativeDarkSolo

Year 2016Dev Daniel Mullins Games

Stores

Quick answer

Within the “Puzzle” category, the closest game to Pony Island is MiSide — scoring 95/100 on our similarity scale. Iron Lung and Five Nights at Freddy's follow close behind.

#1MiSide95 #2Iron Lung95 #3Five Nights at Freddy's94 #4Five Nights at Freddy's 394 #5Five Nights at Freddy's 294

🗳️

Help us build the best rankings

Community powered

Vote on each result below — good match or not. Every vote directly shapes how we rank similar games for everyone.

The best puzzle games like Pony Island

35 similar games foundUpdated July 2026

Handpicked by our similarity algorithm, these are the titles with the highest gameplay match to Pony Island. Each one has been evaluated across 11 real attributes — from combat style and progression mechanics to world structure and visual perspective — so every recommendation is based on how the game actually plays, not just its genre label.

95

MiSide

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeCozyDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 98%· 138KRAWG👍 84%· 137

Year 2024Dev AIHASTO · IndieArkPlaytime ~5hOn PC

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, adventure storytelling and deep simulation

≠ Where it differs: brings deep RPG systems, setting anime and visual first person, while skipping visual pixel

95

Iron Lung

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorPixel Art

Steam👍 92%· 11K

Year 2022Dev David SzymanskiOn PC · PS5 · Switch

✓ Both are psychological horror — sharing horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with setting scifi, exploration and discovery and visual first person, while skipping cozy, relaxing feel

#3Five Nights at Freddy's

94

Five Nights at Freddy's

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorHardcore

Steam👍 94%· 58KIGDB72· 3

Year 2014Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, deep simulation and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: survival mechanics, punishing difficulty and resource management, while skipping cozy, relaxing feel

#4Five Nights at Freddy's 3

94

Five Nights at Freddy's 3

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorMelee

Steam👍 90%· 11KIGDB75· 1

Year 2015Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, deep simulation and adventure storytelling

≠ Where it differs: brings survival mechanics, punishing difficulty and melee combat, while skipping cozy, relaxing feel

#5Five Nights at Freddy's 2

94

Five Nights at Freddy's 2

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloDarkNarrativeHorrorHardcore

Steam👍 94%· 26KIGDB70· 1

Year 2014Dev ScottgamesOn PC

✓ Both are psychological horror — sharing horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Stands apart with survival mechanics, punishing difficulty and visual first person, while skipping cozy, relaxing feel

#6The Last Door - Collector's Edition

96

The Last Door - Collector's Edition

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorPixel Art2D

Steam👍 95%· 2.4KRAWG👍 77%· 66MC79

Year 2014Dev The Game Kitchen · Phoenix Online PublishingPlaytime ~4hOn PC · iOS · Android

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

#7Bonnie Bear Saves Frogtime

96

Bonnie Bear Saves Frogtime

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkCozyHorror2D

Steam👍 87%· 1.0KRAWG👍 74%· 35IGDB72· 3

Year 2016Dev Exordium Games · LibrediaPlaytime ~3hOn PC · Apple Macintosh · Linux

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with fantasy world, while skipping deep simulation

#8Rusty Lake: Roots

96

Rusty Lake: Roots

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 97%· 8.7K

Year 2016Dev Rusty LakeOn Android · PC · iOS

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

Steam GOG itch.io

96

The Cat Lady

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 94%· 6.1K

Year 2012Dev Harvester Games · Screen 7On Linux · PC

✓ Both are psychological horror — sharing horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: exploration and discovery, while skipping deep simulation

96

Detention

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 96%· 12KIGDB76· 3OC81· 33

Year 2017Dev Red Candle Games · Coconut Island GamesOn PS4 · Linux · Android

✓ Both are psychological horror — sharing horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Stands apart with deep RPG systems, survival mechanics and visual novel storytelling, while skipping deep simulation

Steam PS Nintendo

#11Downfall - A Slay the Spire Fan Expansion

96

Downfall - A Slay the Spire Fan Expansion

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 94%· 1.6KRAWG👍 86%· 71MC75

Year 2016Dev Harvester Games · Screen 7Playtime ~4hOn PC

✓ Nearly identical: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design.

≠ Missing: deep simulation.

#12The Black Mirror

96

The Black Mirror

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorror2D

Steam👍 84%· 1.5KIGDB80· 1

Year 2003Dev Future Games · THQ NordicOn PC

✓ Fits the psychological horror cluster, with horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Stands apart with visual third person, while skipping deep simulation

96

Sanitarium

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorIsometric

Steam👍 93%· 1.3KIGDB92· 1

Year 1998Dev DreamForge Intertainment · ASC GamesOn Android · PC · iOS

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Where it differs: brings survival mechanics and visual isometric, while skipping deep simulation

#14Poppy Playtime

96

Poppy Playtime

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorMelee

Steam👍 88%· 138K

Year 2021Dev Mob EntertainmentOn Xbox · PS4 · Android

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, adventure storytelling and puzzle design

≠ Its own twist: survival mechanics, melee combat and visual first person, while skipping deep simulation

Steam Epic Xbox

96

Indika

GenreHorrorSubgenrePsychological Horror

SoloNarrativeDarkHorrorLinear

Steam👍 90%· 8.0KIGDB85· 4OC79· 90

Year 2024Dev Odd Meter · 11 bit studiosOn Xbox · PC · PS5

✓ Same family of psychological horror: horror tension, puzzle design and adventure storytelling

≠ Stands apart with linear, story-driven structure, exploration and discovery and visual third person, while skipping deep simulation

Complete list of puzzle games like Pony Island

The full catalog of games sharing gameplay DNA with Pony Island, ordered from highest to lowest similarity score. Use the filters above to narrow down by genre, setting or game mode and find the alternative that best fits your playstyle.

Explore games similar to Pony Island by category

Rankings in the same genre

Best Psychological Horror Games Best Horror Games